What Does a Barely Passing MEE Answer Look Like

In the realm of legal education and bar examinations, understanding the nuances of the Multistate Essay Examination (MEE) is crucial for aspiring lawyers. This article delves into what constitutes a barely passing MEE answer, exploring the characteristics, structure, and strategies that can help you achieve a passing score. We'll cover the essential elements of an MEE answer, common pitfalls to avoid, and tips for honing your writing skills. Whether you're preparing for the bar exam or simply seeking to improve your legal writing, this comprehensive guide will provide valuable insights.

Understanding the MEE: A Brief Overview

The Multistate Essay Examination (MEE) is a critical component of the bar exam in many jurisdictions across the United States. It consists of a series of essay questions designed to assess a candidate's ability to analyze legal issues and communicate effectively in writing. Each essay is graded on a scale, and a barely passing answer typically scores around 60-65 out of 100. Understanding what this level of performance looks like is essential for anyone preparing for the MEE.

The Purpose of the MEE

The MEE aims to evaluate an applicant's knowledge of various areas of law, including contracts, torts, constitutional law, criminal law, and civil procedure, among others. The questions often require test-takers to apply legal principles to hypothetical scenarios, demonstrating their analytical thinking, legal reasoning, and writing skills.

Format of the MEE

The MEE consists of six essay questions, which are administered over a period of three hours. Each question presents a factual scenario, followed by a prompt that instructs the candidate to analyze specific legal issues. The essays are graded by qualified evaluators who look for clarity, organization, and the application of relevant legal principles.

Characteristics of a Barely Passing MEE Answer

To achieve a barely passing score on the MEE, an answer must exhibit certain characteristics. These include a basic understanding of the relevant law, an attempt to apply that law to the facts presented, and a coherent structure. Below, we break down these essential components.

1. Basic Understanding of Legal Principles

A barely passing answer demonstrates a fundamental grasp of the legal concepts at play. While it may lack depth and nuance, it should correctly identify the primary issues and relevant laws. For instance, if the question pertains to negligence, the answer should mention the elements of negligence: duty, breach, causation, and damages.

2. Application to Facts

Merely stating legal principles is not enough; a barely passing answer must also attempt to apply these principles to the facts of the hypothetical scenario. This application may be superficial or incomplete but should show some effort to connect the law with the given facts. For example, the answer might outline how the defendant's actions could constitute a breach of duty based on the facts provided.

3. Coherent Structure

Organization is key in legal writing. A barely passing answer should have a clear structure, typically including an introduction, body paragraphs that address different issues, and a conclusion. While the arguments may not be fully developed or persuasive, they should follow a logical flow. This structure helps evaluators follow the candidate's reasoning, even if the content is lacking.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Understanding what constitutes a barely passing answer is just as important as knowing what to avoid. Here are some common pitfalls that can hinder performance on the MEE:

1. Failing to Identify Issues

One of the most significant mistakes candidates make is failing to identify the key legal issues presented in the question. A barely passing answer might touch on some relevant points, but it will often miss critical issues, leading to a lack of focus and coherence.

2. Lack of Depth in Analysis

While a barely passing answer may demonstrate a basic understanding of the law, it often lacks depth in analysis. Candidates should strive to explore the implications of their arguments, even if only superficially. A failure to do so can result in a score that barely meets the passing threshold.

3. Poor Writing Mechanics

Grammar, punctuation, and spelling are important in legal writing. A barely passing answer may exhibit frequent errors that distract from the content. While minor mistakes are acceptable, excessive errors can negatively impact readability and overall impression.

Tips for Crafting a Barely Passing MEE Answer

While the goal should always be to exceed the bare minimum, understanding how to craft a barely passing answer can be helpful for those who feel unprepared. Here are some tips to guide you:

1. Read the Question Carefully

Take the time to read the prompt thoroughly. Identify the key legal issues presented and underline or highlight them. This will help you focus your answer on what the examiners are looking for.

2. Outline Your Answer

Before you start writing, create a brief outline of your response. This will help you organize your thoughts and ensure that you address all relevant issues. A structured approach can make a significant difference in clarity and coherence.

3. Be Concise but Relevant

While you want to provide enough information to demonstrate your understanding, avoid unnecessary filler. Be concise and stick to relevant legal principles and their applications. This will help you stay focused and on-topic.

4. Practice Writing Under Time Constraints

Timing is crucial on the MEE. Practice writing essays under timed conditions to get comfortable with the format and pacing. This will help you manage your time effectively during the actual exam.

Sample Barely Passing MEE Answer: An Example

To illustrate what a barely passing MEE answer might look like, consider the following hypothetical question and response:

Hypothetical Question

“A homeowner, Alice, discovers that her neighbor, Bob, is building a fence that encroaches on her property line. Alice confronts Bob, who insists that the fence is within his property rights. Discuss Alice's potential legal claims against Bob.”

Sample Barely Passing Answer

Alice may have a claim against Bob for trespass. Trespass occurs when someone intentionally enters another person's property without permission. In this case, Bob is building a fence on Alice's property, which could be considered an entry onto her land.

Additionally, Alice might claim that Bob is causing a nuisance. A nuisance is an interference with the use and enjoyment of land. If the fence significantly impacts Alice's ability to use her property, she may have a case. However, it is unclear how much the fence affects her enjoyment.

In conclusion, Alice may have claims for trespass and nuisance, but she will need to provide evidence of the encroachment and its impact on her property.

Conclusion: Striving for Improvement

While understanding what a barely passing MEE answer looks like is essential for bar exam preparation, it is crucial to aim higher. The goal should always be to exceed the minimum standards and produce a well-reasoned, comprehensive, and clear response. By practicing regularly, seeking feedback, and refining your writing skills, you can significantly improve your performance on the MEE.

If you're preparing for the MEE, consider joining a study group, enrolling in a prep course, or utilizing online resources to enhance your understanding and skills. Remember, every essay you write is an opportunity to improve, so take the time to reflect on your practice answers and learn from your mistakes.

Further Resources

For more information on the MEE and bar exam preparation, consider visiting the following resources: